Tuesday, March 15, 2011
The universe at large did shake
When You, Incarnate Word of God
Shut up the mouth that brought forth all
The skies, and seas, and moons to wax and wake!
Where they the first time you'd not spake
Since our fierce and fatal fall?
It is a wonder we survived at all
And were not thereby rendered dead
But you had cleaved it to yourself instead
And paid the fiend his ransom - How odd
To Be raised up; To know we're friends of God!
Thursday, January 13, 2011
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Advent Thoughts pt 1
Saturday, November 13, 2010
Monday, October 25, 2010
Stream of Consciousness 2
Thursday, October 21, 2010
Stream of Consciousness 1
Friday, August 6, 2010
Problem of Grace
Adapted from The Council of Orange (529 AD)
Monday, August 2, 2010
Thinking; not thinking
Thursday, July 15, 2010
An E&E statement on Col 3:1-4
"No one longs for eternal, incorruptible, immortal life unless he is wearied of this temporal, corruptible, mortal life." - Augustine
Friday, May 21, 2010
Toys
- A.W. Tozer, Living As a Christian: Teachings from First Peter, p.32
This is something that I have had to struggle with for almost as long as I started to learn about God, the Bible, Christ, and any other theological thing. When I first became a "Christian," I had very little discipleship and as such my mind was left to ponder the deep things of God in a vacuum. Probably the largest errors in my early Christian life was regarding the doctrines of grace, and the Lordship of Christ.
Even while I openly professed Christ as Lord, I was basically practicing antinomianism - a distortion of Biblical Grace that allowed me to continue in my sins so long as I "rededicated" myself at some point when the guilt became too unbearable. Then, I would seek to pay penance and make empty promises about "never doing that again" to prove my commitment to someone that, in all honesty, I never wanted to exist in the first place (and I certainly wasn't living like God was real). I would ask questions like: "Is sin really harmful if it doesn't affect anything? I mean, it's not like God has struck me dead for doing anything. Does that undermine God's justice or does God just have a different sense of justice?" I was in the realm of practical atheism (and had I just admitted it, I don't think my life would have been so conflicted), but I kept pursuing theological things. After I met Jesus five years later, I came to understand that I hadn't really known anything at all.
Let me be honest: There is a large part of me that does not want anything I believe in to be true. It's because I have an internal "victim's mentality"and I try to blame my shortcomings and my doubts on everybody else. "Oh that I hadn't grown up in an Armenian family - then I wouldn't have to struggle with total depravity, limited atonement, and perseverance of the saints (doctrines which I believe to be true)." "Oh that I had been born blind, so that I wouldn't be tempted by my eyes." "Oh that I didn't have such little faith; I could have shown the world God's power by moving mountains or calling bears out to devour those who would insult me!"
Of course, when you boil it down, I'm just blaming God for things that are his right to give and not give. This plays into my learning and teaching because I often don't want the Bible to encourage holy living - I want to do whatever I desire, chalk it up to implulse/evolution/upbringing/ect. and deny that God has the power to change anything --- All while still being a force for good and doing "God's Work" in this world. My early dabblings in theology allowed me to pervert Grace into License , making "take up your cross and follow me" optional. I used the scriptures as toys and instead of letting the law of God encourage holy living, and allowing the grace that God has shown me "bring shalom" to me and give me strength against my accusers.
I have to work at this daily, as my cynical nature doesn't allow me to have blind faith.
Thursday, April 29, 2010
Brief thoughts on the IRFA
Reading about the IRF Act, I understand the concept of the United States promoting religious tolerance and freedom- it is, after all, in line with the Constitution of the United States and it is something that we have enjoyed in America since the Puritans left England. Ideally, this plan of action would lead to more freedom of expression and ideas could be shared and people could be respected.
The practice of said legislation, however, ends up being pure lip service. While the Act allows for sanctions to be made against countries who refuse to "level the playing field" so to speak- and even creates lists of countries that are top offenders- sanctions on the truly egregious offenders are rarely taken. Why?
Money.
China and Saudi Arabia, both notorious religious persecutors are simply ignored. After all, when you import 958,000 barrels of oil into the U.S. everyday (like Saudi Arabia), or when you're the second largest trading partner the U.S. has (i.e. China) - ideals seem to fade in the blinding glow of the dollar.
I'm not one to think that the "American Way" means the best way (or that it means 'God's Way', but that's another blog post), however if this was something that the people of this nation considered important enough to pass into law then two things need to happen:
1) Admit that the report by the USCIRF is correct .
2) Be willing to take a harder stance on those who persecute peaceful religious expression, even if it adversely affects the United States and her allies.
3) Remind countries that receive such sanctions that they are in clear violation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and subsequently bar them from the United Nations.
If these things can't be done, why not repeal the bill and simply leave the ideal in the hearts and minds of people instead of committing it to legally binding paper (even though its already there in kernel form in the First Amendment) ? Doing so would eliminate a redundant program and save taxpayers money.
Friday, April 2, 2010
The second part is this: if you want to be saved, you must not seek salvation through works. God has sent his one and only Son into the world, that we might live through him. He was crucified and died for you and bore your sins in his own body. God has revealed to us by his Word that he will be a merciful Father to us, and without our deserving it (since we can deserve nothing good) he will freely give us remission of sins, righteousness, and everlasting life for the sake of Christ his Son. God gives his gifts freely to everybody, and that is the praise and glory of his divinity. Those who will not receive grace and everlasting life from him freely but want to earn them by their own actions would in this way utterly remove the glory of his divinity. Therefore, so that he may maintain and defend this glory, he is obliged to send his law, like lightning and thunder from heaven, to bruise and break those hard rocks.
This briefly is our doctrine concerning Christian righteousness. Faith justifies because it takes hold of the treasure of Christ's presence. But this presence cannot be comprehended by us because we are in darkness. Therefore, where there is an assured trust of the heart, Christ is present, even in the cloud and obscurity of faith. And this is true formal righteousness, by which a person is justified. Rather than love adorning faith, it is Christ who adorns faith - or rather, he is the true form and perfection of faith. Therefore, Christ, seized by faith and living in the heart, is the true Christian righteousness, for which God counts us righteous and gives us eternal life. This is no work of the law but a quite different sort of righteousness and a certain new world beyond and above the law, for Christ or faith is not the law, nor the work of the law.
True Christianity is, first, being taught by the law to know ourselves and thus learning to say with Paul that "all have sinned and fall short of the Glory of God" (Romans 3:23; see also Psalms 14:3; 51:4; 53:3). When we are humbled by the law and brought to self knowledge, true repentance follows (for true repentance begins with the fear and judgment of God), and we see ourselves to be such great sinners that we find no way to be delivered from sins by our own strength, works, or merits. Then we see what Paul means when he says that man is "sold as a slave to sin" (Romans 7:14) and that "God has bound all men over to disobedience" (Romans 11:32) and that the whole world is guilty before God (Romans 3:19).
Then we begin to sigh and ask who can help us. When we are terrified by the law like this, we utterly despair of our own strength; we look around for the help of a mediator and savior. This is the time for the healing word of the Gospel: "Take heart, son; your sins are forgiven" (Matthew 9:2). Believe in Christ Jesus crucified for you sins. If you feel your sins and the burden of them, do not look upon them in yourself, but remember that they have been transferred and laid on Christ, whose wounds have healed you (Isaiah 53:5).
This is the beginning of heath and salvation. By this means we are delivered from sin, justified, and made inheritors of everlasting life, not because of what we have done to deserve it, but through faith, by which we lay hold of Christ. Therefore, we also acknowledge a quality and a formal righteousness of the heart - not love, but faith, yet such that the heart must see and hold nothing but Christ the Savior.
Christ, truly defined, is no lawgiver but a forgiver of sins and a Savior. He might have paid for all the sins of the world with just one drop of his blood; but now he has shed it plentifully and has satisfied our need abundantly (see Hebrews 9:12; Romans 3-4). It is therefore important to lay hold of Christ by faith, since he bore the sins of the world. Only such faith is counted as righteousness. "
- Martin Luther, Commentary on the Book of Galatians
Monday, March 29, 2010
Worth Doing
"It is a challenging thought, and one that should be closely observed by those who are preparing for a life of service for God, that our divine Lord spent six times as long working at the carpenter's bench as he did in his world-shaping ministry. He did not shrink the hidden years of preparation."From Jesus' example, he goes on to draw a few conclusions. First, it showed that Jesus identified with common, working class people, a fact that would continue to play out in preaching the Gospel of the Kingdom of God. Christ also worked hard as an example of how we should labor for the Father's glory. He drew on his experience from his earthly occupation in his ministry. His mentioning of the "easy yoke" was a possible reflection on this. Finally, he used this time of earthly training to build up stamina for his later ministry. From we have recorded in the gospels, he traveled at least 2500 miles on foot over three years, not counting the mental and spiritual strain. His long hours as a carpenter prepared him for what came next.
As far as my own work goes, last night I was reminded that I have an opportunity to minister to people in subtle ways. There was a lady and her husband who live in the independent units on the campus of the assisted living facility I work for. She is very weak after battling cancer for many years and he is too frail to help her up. I got to bring comfort by helping her to bed twice in one night. She cried each time, and hugged me close while her husband just smiled and said "She just wants a little loving, you know?" Now, my job isn't rocket science. It's not overly hard (other than being away from my wife two/three nights a week), but it does get rather monotonous. It more of a mental battle to stay away and diligent. Sometimes it's easy to forget Colossians 3:17 : that in "whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him."
I want to be more grateful for the things I take for granted. Hopefully, this is a good first step.
Thursday, March 18, 2010
The Rationality of God
Many people believe in what is called classical foundationalism. This is the belief that everything must be based on sensory experience or self-evident truths. This leads to eventialism, which is probably best summized by a quote from English mathematician and philosopher William K. Clifford from his essay The Ethics of Belief:
"It is wrong always, everywhere, and for anyone, to believe anything upon insufficient evidence."
There is certainly a lot to be unpacked from that statement, but a more formal way of wording this argument as it applies to belief in god looks like this:
(1) Belief in God is rational only if there is sufficient evidence for the existence of God.
(2) There is not sufficient evidence for the existence of God.
(3) Therefore, belief in God is irrational.
Now, as this is a valid argument, the theist has a few options. Either the theist accepts what is said as true and either a) forsakes belief in God. or b) admits the belief is irrational and continues believing anyway; or the theist works to refute one of the premises and show it to be an invalid argument.A large number of Christians, especially evangelicals, tend to argue against the second premise. They point to things such as the universe existing in the first place (the Cosmological Argument), the universe showing signs of intelligent design (the Teleological Argument), the concept of morality (Moral Argument), or the fact that we can conceive of God in the first place (the Ontological Argument). While these arguments are valuable, they are also easy to dispute. Random chance with an assumption of eternal matter takes the place of the Cosmological argument. Macro-Evolution takes the place of the Teleological and Moral arguments. The Ontological Argument is often written off as bad grammar.
The second way of refuting this argument, called Reformed Epistemology, attacks the second premise. It makes belief in God foundational, that is, it says that belief in God is rational without the support of evidence or argument. Some of the grounds for this are as follows:
Demand for "sufficient evidence" can't be met consistently. That is, many things that people consider to be completely rational do not have a shred of evidence attached to them. Try proving the existence of other people, or that yesterday happened. No one can prove these things, yet it is perfectly rational to know that these things will happen. So belief in God is more akin to belief in other people, rather than belief in an scientific equation. Secondly, as it is rational to trust in what other people tell us, in the belief of the past, ect. so it is rational to belief that we are rational if these experiences produce in us belief in God. (This is what Calvin called the sensus divinitatus, or "sense of the divine".)
In wrapping this up, I think it is important to examine and question one's belief. Understanding what you believe and why you believe it are essential regardless of one's worldview. Doubting your faith, or having a theistic argument make sense to you (for the atheist), does not mean that one should instantly tear down everything you believe in. People have good reasons for belief as well as disbelief. As long as healthy dialogue and intellectual honesty is maintained, truth will prevail. As a theist, I find that reformed epistemology works well in explaining my conversion and it helps me in retaining my faith. "Believing so that I may understand", I continue in spite of my doubt.
Links to lots of things that cover what I talked about in much, much greater detail:
Without Evidence or Argument: A Defense of Reformed Epistemology
Religious Epistemology (The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Philosophy of Religion
The Ethics of Belief by William K. Clifford
The Knowledge of God the Creator by John Calvin (Institutes, book I)
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Pride Comes Before
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Unedited Thoughts and Progressive Arguments
Now, however, I want to post something I wrote last night. As you may or may not be aware, I work night shift security and I get lots of time to think about things. I'm just going to post some unedited thoughts. It started out sort of poetical, but ended up in a different place. There's a lot to unpack and I'd like comments if possible.
______
Everyone has moments where thought
Becomes impossible, impotent, improbable
And a threshold that, when crossed,
Forces their ego to escape, id to escape,
Superego to shrivel, wither, diminish
Self is for naught
If it's about "becoming"
Rather than Being (Not that we experience it in that pure way)
We look to squeeze blood from a stone
The water of becoming from the rock of being
And in the process, we fail to see progress
Because their is none
And no other way things could be.
To some, this is the wellspring of hope
To others, damnation
God exists in the Ever-Now, timeless.
"It may be that He has the eternal appetite of infancy; for we have sinned and grown old, and our Father is younger than we."
Perhaps we experience "change" on this side of time because we are soaking it in, imbibing it.
What we are is already fixed and now we simply realize how it is we are made: for holy use or common. If God is the God of the Living, not the dead: Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob live - hidden with Christ in God with all the elect - a process we experience in time as sanctification. It's a finished process; God creates at the beginning and triumphs at the end. "Christ will be in agony until the end of the world."; world without end, Amen.
This is too heavy for complete disclosure.
I think about these things when I desire to see change in my life and it has not come. I believe it will come because of the promise. Credo ut intelligam. So even in my doubt, I do not stop believing.
Praise be to God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ who resurrects us from the dead and puts flesh on dry bones that then dare to dance! May all flesh come to fear and know him!
____
Friday, January 29, 2010
A Note on Bazan
After their demise, Bazan went solo and while I enjoyed his work with Headphones, I started to see a darker trend in his lyrics. With his solo EP Fewer Moving Parts, I thought the situation mostly absolved, but something felt different. In a few discussions with friends who checked out his newest album Curse Your Branches, I realized, probably for the first time that Bazan had abandoned the faith almost entirely. This latest album is harsh and cynical - but in a much more overt way than previous projects at least to my ears. However, I understand that this is simply the logical conclusion once a person of faith finally manages, for whatever reason or in whatever way, to undermine the very foundation of their convictions. I realized that we had reached two different conclusions. The lynchpin, as it seems often the case, is the traditional problem of evil.
I'm not going to attempt to solve the problem of evil in this post, however, for the sake of clarity, I will say that I do understand the problem of evil to be a real problem. It's logically valid, if the given premises are true. I find a few of the premises to be questionable (and therefore, my faith to be logically true), but it isn't something I take lightly. It's still there. It's stolen former friends away from the faith because they could not hold faith and wrestle with the problem of evil or because they bought into (and perhaps misapplied) the philosophy of Descartes, scrapped their entire worldview, and attempted to build it back up from scratch with themselves at the center (leaving out God completely, as some of Descartes later critics would).
I'm still watching Bazan, albeit from a distance now. I have always loved his honesty, and I even continued to support him after the rather infamous moment where he showed up to the Cornerstone Festival drunk with a full jug of vodka on stage. I'm not naive enough to spin his new lyrics into anything else than they are: a call to question one's beliefs and recaps of fairly harsh life stories. I have no problem with either, but it does give one pause to think about how people reach different conclusions with similar backgrounds. I'd wager Bazan and myself would come to different conclusions on that as well.
In any case, I do still recommend any and all of Pedro the Lion's body of work. It's best when enjoyed with a strong beer or something stronger - in moderation, of course.
Friday, January 8, 2010
Part 2
Without further ado. . .
_______________________
Those who cannot reconcile the image of the crucified Christ with that of the sword bearer that divides - those unwilling or unable to see and embrace the apparent contradictions must examine the full text to get a full picture of the God we serve. War and peace, wrath and love, the death of Death, and the union between God and Man are all central to the faith Christians hold in common. Those unwilling to do this find themselves alienated, and without correction will not come to fully understand the true depth, breath, length, and width that the Cross of Christ communicates to this defiled world. In the cross, Christ, our fully human, fully God, gave himself as a propitiation for us, making atonement for the sins of those who would come to believe in him. God is not angry with us. His wrath has been satisfied and Christians are saved from that wrath, not into comfort or safety, but into good works by the power of the Holy Spirit. If he had not done this, we would not be able to approach a God who, because of his holiness, would have consumed us as straw thrown into a fire. Not only does he save us from the wrath of God, but Jesus is raised from the dead for our justification: All authority is given to him and he intercedes for the sins of his elect and for the exaltation of the Church universal. This Church would divide the world, and sunder it with the message of Revolution and Redemption - separating the sheep of his flock from the goats, uniting the profane with the holy by justifying his enemies, walking two miles and heaping hot coals on their emeies heads in perfect love, and hardening (not softening) the hearts of the establishment with God's perfect symbol of Grace and Wrath and Redemption - The Cross of Christ; this the basis of faith, the catalyst of hope, and the foundation of all true community.
Thursday, December 31, 2009
Politics, and Holding Paradoxes
In Jesus for President, Shane Claiborne and Chris Haw outline and accentuate what they believe to be the politics of Jesus and attempt to spur the reader to live counter-cultural lives that emulate Jesus' teachings. They should be commended for some of their scholarship. Many people in the Church today no longer know of, much less consider, the political climate in which the New Testament was written. To take this information into account then, upholds one of the basic tenants of hermeneutics: historical context.
That being said, my issue is not with the idea of living a humble life in bearing one's cross and suffering hardship for the kingdom of God. This, I believe, is the main point of the book that gets clouded by some fairly serious matters that the authors don't address directly. In the "Co-opted and Confused" section on p.194, there is a quote from Mark Driscoll which came from Relevant magazine:
"Some emergent types [want] to recast Jesus as a limp-wrist hippie in a dress with a lot of product in His hair, who drank decaf and made pithy Zen statements about life while shopping for the perfect pair of shoes. In Revelation, Jesus is a prize fighter with a tattoo down His leg, a sword in His hand and the commitment to make someone bleed. That is a guy I can worship. I cannot worship the hippie, diaper, halo Christ because I cannot worship a guy I can beat up".
Following this, there is a quote from Paul derived from 1 Cor 1:23 "I preach Christ crucified".
I was confused at first, because I failed to see how both of these things aren't true. Driscoll is merely recalling how Christ is pictured at the end of the Age: triumphant, and coming in judgment, his enemies being made a footstool under his feet. You may also recall Jesus' words in Matthew 10:34-35:
"Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law."
G.K. Chesterton has many things to say about holding contradictions. In Orthodoxy, Chesterton sees doctrine as the main thrust of managing the contradictions of peace and war. "By defining its main doctrine, the Church not only kept seemingly inconsistent things side by side, but, what was more, allowed them to break out in a sort of artistic violence otherwise possible only to anarchists". The Cross of Christ, and orthodox Christianity as defined in the Apostle's Creed is the linchpin of his entire discussion.
In reading Jesus for President, I began to get the feeling that the Cross of Christ was being misrepresented, even if only indirectly. This is something that was deeply unsettling, and I must admit, not knowing the authors personally, I was unsure if I was reading too much into their views or if some of their other views were unstated. The view put forward was one of example - but only one of example: i.e. "He himself was like a sheep killed by wolves. By freely accepting crucifixion, he demonstrated what a sheep among wolves looks like" (p. 277). No mention of Christ's atoning work at all. While I understood the thrust of the book was not "theological" in nature, the implied denial of this cornerstone of Christianity flirts with heresy. At the very least it limits the true breath and depth of the Cross of Christ to mere moralism and a social gospel that doesn't save anyone.
Monday, December 28, 2009
The Obligitory Purpose Statement, ect.
Greetings.
As my first semi-serious foray into the blogosphere, I thought I might add a bit of a purpose statement, and try to express succinctly what purpose another theological blog might serve.
One of the clearest issues in the Body of Christ today is that of community. It is community that I seek as I voice my opinions and seek to learn from other traditions of the faith, and hear the concerns of seekers and skeptics. I hope that critique can flow from both sides of debate and that we can find common ground, but first: my background.
I consider myself to be Reformed in my theology. I get fed the most by people like Augustine, Calvin, R.C. Sproul, John Piper, and Mark Driscoll (to name a few). I also seek to balance my theology by reading works of early church fathers, the puritans, and Christian classics. I do this because I believe that our problems are not the problems of the previous generations, but can correct our thinking on the places we are found wanting (for more on this, read "On the Reading of Old Books" by C.S. Lewis). I am married to a wonderful woman who is much more of a reader than I am and I just recently graduated from Columbia International University.
Well, that's an overview. I hope the quality of these posts improves and that we can have good discussions, pray for each other, avoid quagmires, and die on hills that should be defended.
"For I do not understand in order to believe; I believe in order to understand. For I also believe that 'Unless I believe, I shall not understand'". (Anselm, Proslogion)